Q Magazine
1990
By John Bauldie. Review of the
1989 CD re-issue
SPACE ODDITY (Ryko) Those who weren't quite quick enough to snap up the hastily
deleted RCA Records CD releases of this LP have had an unexpectedly long
wait for them to reappear in CD format. But, like Major Tom, here they come
circling into view once more, remastered by Rykodisc Records and, as if
to compensate for the delay, each boasting bonus tracks.
....Space Oddity
(once called David Bowie (1969), a handful of ditties from the Beckenham
Arts Lab and a couple of extravagant exclamations of post-hippy disenchantment
bundled haphazardly with the hit title track, was repackaged in September
1972 to cash in on the Ziggy star-days. Omitted from the rerelease, the
less frantic version of Unwashed
And Somewhat Slightly Dazed with its silly 20-second coda, Don't Sit
Down, is here restored to its original place, while tagged on as over-matter
are both sides of the seemingly interminable single version of the embarrassing
Memory Of A Free Festival and
Conversation Piece, originally the
b-side of the Prettiest Star single.
But is the Prettiest Star single itself here? No, it isn't. Neither is Ragazzo Solo, Ragazza Sola, the Italian
language version of Space Oddity,
nor the original acoustic version of one of the LP's best tracks, The Wide-Eyed Boy From Freecloud, once
to be found on the flip of the Space Oddity 45.
....Each time, then,
the extra tracks come as undesirable adjuncts, serving only to spoil the
listening experience. Far better, surely, to have bumped the lot of them,
along with the handful of contemporary tracks that remain unheard (including
a 1970 song to David Bowie's recalcitrant old car, Rupert
The Riley), on to a special Rarities CD and left the original tracks
to stand alone. It would mean minutes lopped off the playing time, sure,
but sometimes more doesn't necessarily mean better.
Q Rating: ** |